Whether I'm pro or against this is hard to say, but I'll make an example of this:
On minestatus, every month the votes are reset to 0. Is it far for the number 1 spot to lose all those votes they got? No. But it's not fair for them to have such a larger advantage over the others. I mean, they get front page for an entire month. If minestatus resets, it gives everyone the same chance again, even the new servers. If stats are WAY easier to get, then just train and it'll be easier. Persoanlly I'd see it as fun to retrain again, start from the top and go again. I know most of the people who are complaining right now have complained about "The server has nothing to do anymore, I'm bored!" Well, here's the problem, you're too good. Time to knock you down again and make it fun again. Like in pokemon, when you beat the elite 4, do you go around beating the elite 4 over and over and over again? Maybe a few times but eventually it's not fun. It's funner to restart it and start a whole new adventure. Just my opinion.