From what I know.
Old Elites:
1. Blaze
2. Tene
3. Mario
4. Vithrus
Tn challenged and beat all the Elites, Mario quit, Tn lost to TA ending his challenge. With only 3 Elites remaining, Frenzy challenges, loses to Blaze an earns himself 1st Elite. Shish challenges and beats Frenzy, he now has to battle Blaze.
Hope this clears things up.