OK obvious Rules broken for sure. (Only basing proof off what a person has actually admitted to doing).
1. Z4 Obviously broke RULE 1, first.
2. Frenzy Broke rule 1 also,
3. Barn Broke Rule 1 as well,
4. Everyone broke rule 1, never let up feeding the madness with their excessive trolling
5. Frenzy Never Admitted To Using Pots, I believe he has the right of until proven guilty. Obviously I'm not taking Barn's, or Z4's plea that he was as actually using the terrible things, cause people can "Say" a lot of things.
6. Z4 admitted that he was using the /sethome command.
"<PokeModbot> <Frenzy_Monkey47> How the FUCK are they GETTING in?!
<PokeModbot> <Z4X3R> Sethomes
<PokeModbot> <Frenzy_Monkey47> Thats ilegal"
7. Barn did not admit that he was using the /sethome command, and like Frenzy I believe he has the right of "Until proven guilty".
My vote is as follows (for what it's worth)
Frenzy gets a minor punishment for breaking rule one, whatever that punishment may be (mute I think), for excessive ignorance to the first rule perhaps a temp ban.
Barn gets a similar punishment as frenzy for breaking the first rule, the same as Frenzy. He did not actually admit to using the /sethome command to warp to Frenzys room, and I don't see any proof but Frenzy's word of him doing so. Under the belief that he was just returning to his VIP room via the /warp command, or walking there with an open door, that does not break any rules.
Z4 gets an advanced ban for breaking the first rule on multiple occasions, and using the /sethome command to return to Frenzy's VIP room.
Note: It is true that it has been said that if there is PVP enabled in someone's home, store, or personal rooms, then the punishment of killing another player is denied, cause the incident could of happened vice-versa. Thus I think the word mostly used "Camping" should be ignored due to the fact that Z4 and Barn were only following this rule.
*Z4 however did admit of setting his home inside Frenzy's VIP room, which is a bannable offense
*Barn did not admit that he was using /sethome to enter Frenzy's VIP room, which I think he deserves the right to be innocent till proven guilty.
I'm not trying to take sides. Personally I find myself a friend to Z4, and Frenzy. I actually find Z4 as one of my better friends on the server. It just seems that most are pinning down on Z4, when Frenzy did feed the flames with his trolling after killing them, when he could of just ignored them, reported them, and only they would have been punished for breaking Rule 1 (as via the announcement on respecting those who are mean to you, to be the better person announcement).
TL;DR, just a commoner throwing in an opinion. Can be easily ignored, cause it's best these dealings be disputed between the admins. I'm sure you will always pass rightful judgement, and we love you all.